Key Takeaways
- Your number comes from your spending, not your income: annual spending minus guaranteed income, divided by a sustainable withdrawal rate.
- A 4% starting withdrawal rate is a reasonable planning anchor; flexibility in bad markets matters more than the exact figure.
- Most people are closer than the headlines suggest once Social Security and spending reality are counted.
The honest formula is short: estimate what a year of your retirement costs, subtract the income that shows up regardless (Social Security, any pension), and divide the remainder by a sustainable withdrawal rate, around 4% is a defensible planning anchor. Spend $110,000, collect $40,000 of Social Security, and the portfolio must cover $70,000 a year: at 4%, roughly $1.75 million.
Everything else, the headlines, the "you need $3 million" posts, the rules of thumb keyed to salary, is noise until it is your spending in the numerator.
Start with Real Spending, Not a Multiplier
Salary multipliers fail because two households earning $300,000 can live on $90,000 and $250,000 respectively, and their retirements cost accordingly. Pull twelve months of actual spending, then adjust for retirement reality: the mortgage may be gone, payroll taxes and retirement saving disappear, health insurance before Medicare gets expensive, and early-retirement travel often raises spending for a decade before it drifts down. Many retirees follow a "smile" pattern: higher spending early, lower in the middle, higher again late as care costs arrive.
What a Withdrawal Rate Really Promises
The 4% guideline comes from historical testing: a portfolio of stocks and bonds, spending 4% of the starting value adjusted for inflation each year, survived every historical 30-year period in the U.S. data. It is a stress-tested worst case, not an average; in most historical paths that retiree died far richer than they started. Reasonable people adjust it: a touch lower for very early retirement or expensive markets, higher if you can cut spending in bad years, which is the single most powerful safety valve.
Model your own numbers in the free Retirement Readiness calculator.
Try it: the free Retirement Readiness Calculator takes a couple of minutes and shows you where you stand. Or explore retirement planning at Attend.
Count the Income That Shows up Anyway
Social Security is real money and most projections at ssa.gov understate a high earner's benefit by defaulting to early claiming. A couple with strong earnings histories can see $60,000 to $80,000 a year with delayed claiming, which at a 4% withdrawal rate substitutes for $1.5 to $2 million of portfolio. Pensions, rental income, and part-time work in the early years all reduce the number the same way. This is why "how much do I need" and "when should I claim" are one question, not two.
From Number to Plan
Once the target exists, the plan writes itself: current savings, contribution rate, and expected return produce a trajectory, and the gaps show up as specific fixes, save more, retire eighteen months later, spend slightly less, or take sensible portfolio risk instead of sitting in cash. Revisit the number every year or two; it moves less than markets do, and watching it converge is genuinely motivating.
We turn this arithmetic into a full plan, taxes, withdrawal sequencing, and all, in our retirement planning work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is $1 million enough to retire?
For a household spending $60,000 with $35,000 of Social Security, comfortably. For one spending $200,000, no. The portfolio requirement is spending-driven; there is no universal number.
Should I plan to age 90 or 100?
For a healthy couple at 65, plan for at least one spouse reaching the mid-90s. Longevity risk is the one mistake you cannot fix later; err long.
How does inflation fit in?
The withdrawal-rate framework already assumes inflation-adjusted spending. What deserves separate attention is health care, which inflates faster than the general basket, and any fixed pension that does not adjust.

Tony leads Attend Wealth, a fee-based wealth management firm in Atlanta serving professionals, families, and business owners. Advisory services are held to a fiduciary standard. More about Attend
Talk It Through with a Fiduciary Advisor.
A complimentary conversation about your situation. Ask whatever is on your mind, walk away with a straight answer, and keep the notes either way.
Book Your Complimentary Consult